On Wednesday, the International AIDS Society
(IAS) presented the Treatment Guidelines for Antiretroviral Therapy 1998.
BackgroundHIV viral load <20 copies/mL plasma is equivalent to
approximately 105 copies in the human body.
RNA at 1 year of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) is
- predictable RNA at 16 weeks; and
- very dependent upon adherence.
- Bad news patients fail therapy :
- Difficulties with adherence (e.g. pill burden, side effects);
- Resistance to drugs prior to therapy;
- Therapy too weak (doomed to fail).
- However, biological activity does not necessarily equal clinical efficacy.
Four questions remain at the centre of
these treatment guidelines
When to initiate therapy?
Which drugs to begin with?
When to change therapy?
Which drugs to switch to?
Prior to initiation of therapy
Two plasma HIV-RNA measurements > 5,000-10,000 copies/mL;
Two CD4+ T cell counts;
If RNA remains at < 5,000-10,000 copies/mL and CD4 > 350-500, treatment may be
deferred.
Which drugs to begin with?
Since the world AIDS meeting in Vancouver (1996), the options have increased
substantially and include:
- PI + 2 nRTIs
- NNRTI + 2nRTIs
- 2 PIs +/- 1 or 2 nRTIs
- 1 PI + 1 NNRTI or an nRTI
- 3 nRTIs
Protease Inhibitor (PI); nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor
(nRTI); nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NNRTI).
- Several variables might be taken into account in choosing the initial regimen:
- Evidence from clinical trials
- Potency of drug regimen
- Desire to preserve future treatment options (cf. risk of cross-resistance)
- Drug-drug interactions
- Side effects
- Clinician familiarity with drugs
- Cost/availability
When to change therapy?
The obvious answer is "when treatment fails," but what exactly
is "treatment failure?"
- New symptoms;
- Development of an opportunistic infection;
- Toxicity/Intolerance.
- Loss of control of viral replication (either detectable when previously undetectable
or never becoming undetectable).
- Reasons for treatment failure include (but are not limited to):
- Toxicity;
- Resistance (both genotypic and phenotypic);
- Pharmacodynamic factors (i.e., Is the drug reaching its target?);
- Adherence.
Controversy remains about whether to switch early or late. Logic
might argue that delaying a switch might preserve treatment options but no evidence
really exists to prove the argument either way.
Which drugs to switch to?
The rules are:
- Confirm that failure has taken place;
- Avoid sequential monotherapy;
- Change 2 (and ideally ALL) drugs at one time;
- When recycling drugs, wait several cycles;
- Measure viral load regularly;
- Discuss all changes to schedule fully with patient;
- Define criteria for success and failure early on.
Treatment must be individualized based on clinical judgement about
viral load, history of antiretroviral treatment, the patients response to treatment
and the patients clinical history.
Effects of Antiretroviral Therapy
Increased drug use, increased costs and increased out-patient visits
Dramatically decreased inpatient bed use, reduced costs and mortality (since 3TC)
European median survival rates differ by region
once CD4 < 50 cells/mm3
- Southern Europe: 19 months
- Northern Europe: 23 months
- Central Europe: 40 months
These differences were accounted for by differential use of HAART
"Immune restoration disease"
Potent antiretroviral therapy may cause flare of clinically silent
opportunistic infections, because of increasing inflammation at the site of organisms
MAC
tuberculosis
CMV retinitis/encephalitis
Hepatitis C
herpes simplex virus
varicella zoster virus
Generally occurs within the first 8 weeks of therapy
Associated with low CD4 counts and no prophylaxis
Antiretroviral Treatment in Pregnancy
General principles
- antiretroviral treatment of mother
- prevention of HIV transmission to infant, especially at around birth
- combination antiretroviral therapy preferable to zidovudine monotherapy
- if on treatment, avoid therapy for 1st 12 weeks (with view of avoid any
potential for foetal damage)
Treatment for the Rest of the World
Estimates of cost effectiveness of :
- opportunistic infection prophylaxis $370 per year of life saved
- dual RTI therapy $2,000 per year of life saved
Tuberculosis
Rifampicin/pyrazinamide 2/12 vs. INH 6-12/12
similar efficacy
adverse events similar (low in both)
adherence in Uganda was related to economic factors of patient
less effective in hospitals without a microscope
resistance in northern Thailand:
Isoniazid 14%
Rifampicin. 13%
Multidrug resistant 8% (even higher in young adults)
Ethambutol a safe effective substitute for thiacetazone (a common cause
of severe hypersensitivity reactions)
|